Joseph Weisenthal RSS

joecontemplativeStuff that doesn't fit on Twitter or The Stalwart.

Archive

Jul
26th
Sun
permalink

John Carney’s Ridiculous Anti-Cronkite Essay

brianvan:

I have to agree that John Carney’s thinly-veiled contempt at Cronkite seems to lack a logical base, his argument is unusually unconvincing, and I have to assume that it’s just some irrational political-based grudge.

True.

I agree with the sentiment, though, that it was bad for our national dialogue that Cronkite was the monolithic news figure of his time, that he had no competition or debate equal; things are somewhat better now, even if many of the TV pundits of modern times are irresponsible blowhards.

To be honest, I’ve never understood it when people in 2009 talk smack about the way the media was in the 60s or 70s or really anytime pre-internet. It was that way because it had to be that way. It wasn’t “bad” and it wasn’t “good” or anything. It just had to be that way due to technological necessity.

I’ve heard people criticize newspapers for being a random mishmash of horoscopes, cartoons, op-eds, golf coverage, stock tables and “news.” But someone should try going back to any point in the 1900s and create a commercial product that was something different? What we have now is better, but I guarantee that in 2100 they’ll look back at our crap now. It doesn’t mean that we, today, have to consider it bad.

  1. jayyarow reblogged this from josephweisenthal and added:
    think this is Joe’s attempt at getting...Mediaite, but whatever, this is good stuff....
  2. web20morons reblogged this from brianvan and added:
    YOU SHOULD GET A JOB. YOU SHOULD, YOU SHOULD, AND YOU SHOULD
  3. brianvan reblogged this from josephweisenthal and added:
    I’m critical of both eras because I know we can do better. It is, in part, because network news is driven by a...
  4. josephweisenthal reblogged this from brianvan and added:
    honest, I’ve never understood it when people...anytime pre-internet. It
  5. peterfeld reblogged this from youngmanhattanite and added:
    your provocative thesis, I’d say — fine,...don’t blame Cronkite, blame Freda Payne.
  6. youngmanhattanite reblogged this from josephweisenthal and added:
    Cronkite was wrong about the Vietnam War and helped contribute to the loss of confidence in the cause of South...
  7. josephweisenthal posted this